One thing is certain:
If the Patels had been around before the birth of
Christ, Joseph and Mary would not have had to hear
the stressful words, “No Room at the Inn.” These tenacious
moteliers, noted for turning rundown properties into
successful ventures, would have somehow managed to
find room to accommodate two more people!
Indeed, what started out as modest mom and pop operations
in the 1950s and was often the butt of motel/Potel
jokes has evolved into a true American success story.
We’re talking $38 billion – that’s billion with a
B – the market value of hotels belonging to the 6000
members of Asian American Hotel Owners Association
(AAHOA).
Together this miniscule percentage of the American
population owns more than 18,000 hotels with one million
rooms. They hire 800,000 people and own over one third
of all the hotels in the United States. When you look
at the mid market segment, they own a whopping 50
percent of the hotels. Not bad for an immigrant population
that came with just a suitcase to this country and
ended up providing a roof, a TV and a comfortable
bed to millions of travelers across America, reliving
the Hindu maxim of hospitality, “The guest is God.”
The vast majority of these Indian motel owners came
from India, England and Africa, where their lives
had been disrupted by the whims of the despot Idi
Amin in Uganda. They also came from Kenya and Malawi,
seeking better life and education. Most brought assets
with them and a common cultural link. In fact, their
common Gujarati heritage and the Patel clan connections
were a source of strength and family unity.
B.U. Patel’s
Tarsadia Group has some of the swankiest Indian American
hotel properties.
Many of these would-be hoteliers came to the United
States in the late 1960s and 1970s for higher education
in accounting, mathematics, engineering and medicine.
Family members followed from India and England on
family reunification visas, thus providing many more
hands to run entrepreneurial ventures.
“What you are witnessing is an American Dream that
our members are pursuing. You see it in the growth
of AAHOA and the entrepreneurial spirit being showcased
in the hotel landscape of the United States,” observes
Fred Schwartz, president of AAHOA.
AAHOA is an advocacy group in the hospitality industry.
It publishes AAHOA Lodging business magazine and organizes
educational seminars, regional trade shows, legal
services for its members.
“There is tremendous family support and without this
the growth would not have been as fast as it has been,”
says Hasmukh Rama, the head of one of the most successful
hotel families, the JHM Group, based in Greenville,
S.C. The Ramas are Gujaratis from Africa and all five
brothers — Hashmukh, Jayanti, Manhar, Denu and Raman
— have combined their diverse expertise in fields
like architecture, accounting and engineering to create
a corporation which owns 38 hotels. Hashmukh Rama
speaks of a sense of community, in which more established
members of the community provided advice and financial
help to newcomers. The hospitality industry was a
popular choice because it offered immediate housing
and cash flow, as well as a chance to get a toehold
in America despite cultural and sometimes, language
barriers.
The early years were not without problems, as many
of these hoteliers met with resistance, especially
from bankers and insurance companies, some of whom
subscribed to an Indian conspiracy to buy hotels,
burn them, and collect on insurance. There was also
an underlying racism, with “American owned” motels
signs shoving elbows at guests contemplating the hospitality
of those run by “foreigners.”
When Little India did a cover story on the motel industry
in 1994, the Indian hoteliers were already a force,
having created a $20 billion empire from sweat and
elbow grease, building a mighty hospitality structure,
one small mom and pop establishment at a time, through
family unity, sheer hard work and “Patel equity,”
where members of the community helped their kin to
get ahead with loans and other support.
Now, almost a decade later, Little India revisited
the motels — and found some big changes. First things
first: these Indian American entrepreneurs no longer
like to be called “moteliers,” having upgraded themselves
to the status “hoteliers.” You won’t find too many
independent mom and pop outfits anymore, as franchised
properties have become the rage.
Tarsadia Hilton.
Even in 1994, many Indians were getting into the mid-range
franchises and 30-40 percent of Holiday Inn, Days
Inn and Comfort Inn franchises were operated by Indian-American.
Many small motel owners who had independent no name
brands have moved on to mid-range franchises, such
as Choice Hotels, Best Western, Baymont Hotels, and
Carlson, which includes the Country Inn and Suites.
Cendant Corporation’s Hotel Group, based in Parsippany,
N.J., is the world’s largest lodging franchiser with
6,551 open hotels representing 539,482 rooms on five
continents under the Super 8, Days Inn, Ramada, Travelodge,
Howard Johnson, Knights Inn, Villager, Wingate Inn
and AmeriHost Inn brands. Almost 40 percent of Cendant’s
hotel franchisees are Asian American. Now hoteliers
are expanding their reach, adding on classier, bigger
properties like Marriott, Holiday Inn and Hilton,
which also owns Hampton, Six Continents, and U.S.
Franchises. B.U. Patel who started out in 1976 with
a single 20-room Dunne Motel in Anaheim, Calif., has
with his two sons Mike and Tushar, created a portfolio
of hotels which include full-service and all-suite
properies, including the AAA Four Diamond award winning
476-room Marriott in San Mateo, Calif.
Tarsadia Hotels also redeveloped the 400-room Hyatt
Regency Orange County near Disneyland Resort into
a 670-room, 60,000 square foot conference center and
convention hotel. It has also completed an extensive
$25 million makeover of the lobby and guestrooms at
the 1033-room Anaheim Marriott.
Indeed, many hoteliers are steadily moving to bigger
and more upscale properties. According to Naresh ‘Nash’
Patel, secretary of AAHOA, “Our members run 57 percent
of the economy lodging industry, and we’d like to
take that to 75 percent. We have 36 percent of the
full service hotels and we’d like to add at least
another 10 percent in the next few years time. It’s
a very achievable task given how the community has
taken and harnessed the industry, and we provide our
members the expertise to secure financing and develop
hotels.”
So who are the biggest names in the hospitality business?
Mike Amin with
AAHOA keynoter Bill Bennett.
Mahesh Mike Amin, chairman of the AAHOA Board, is
reluctant to name names as he says such a list would
be highly subjective. “Most of our membership is privately
held and there are very few publicly traded or investment
oriented companies out there. Most of them are independent
operators — majority of our members own one, two or
three assets. They are not large management companies
or hotel corporations, but yet are a significant percentage
in the hotel industry.”
But there are a handful of big players. Such as BU
Patel and his sons Mike and Tushar of the Tarsadia
Hotels, in Orange County, Calif., with over 16 properties;
the Rama brothers of JHM Hotels, which has close to
3,800 rooms; the father and son team of Bharat Shah
and Mitesh Shah of Noble Investments, based in Atlanta,
Ga., owning about 25 properties; Shree Hospitality
Group in North Carolina, headed by Ravi Patel, has
24 hotels. The Diplomat Companies headed by R.C. Patel
and his brother Mike Patel operate several hotels
in the Southeast.
The second — and sometimes the third — generation
has come of age, the family-owned businesses are getting
a fresh shot in the arm from young blood. Getting
into the saddle is a savvy band of hoteliers who may
have grown up as “motel kids,” but are bringing their
American education, professional expertise and way
of life into their parents’ business.
The current AAHOA chairman Amin, is just 37 and is
a third generation hotelier in California. “Ours is
a simple story, no different from any other immigrant
who immigrated to America,” says Amin, whose grandfather
migrated from Surat in Gujarat to San Francisco in
1953: “He was fortunate to be chosen for a lotto system
of immigration from India to America, which existed
in the late ‘40s and early ‘50s. Through savings and
hard work, he managed to lease his first hotel in
1956, in an alley in the South of Market area in San
Francisco.”
Rama Brothers.
That initial property has expanded over the years
to The Amin Group, a commercial management and development
firm with several properties. Mike Amin, who studied
economics and business at the University of San Francisco,
and earned a BS in finance and marketing, brings expertise
in new venture management, financial management and
real estate law and analysis, to the table.
He has been active in AAHOA, advocating political
awareness, grassroots activism and ongoing education
for independent hoteliers. He says, “Education and
second and third generations entering the business
is not only good, but adds more quality to the overall
product and operation.”
Amin is just one of the many American-born children
of immigrant hoteliers who are helping to take the
hospitality business to the next level. D.J. Rama
is a second-generation hotelier whose father and four
uncles founded the JHM Group. D.J. Rama, who completed
his masters in hospitality management from Cornell
University, is the first of his generation to join
the family business, while others are still in college.
“A lot of the AAHOA members are graduating themselves
and upgrading their portfolios, selling these smaller
properties and moving into larger markets with a higher
brand name,” says D.J. Rama, who is a director of
the organization. “Because they now have a stronger
balance sheet they’ve been able to leverage that to
borrow more money and to build or purchase hotels
and reposition them in the marketplace.”
Sudhir and Priti
Patel.
He adds: “The Asian hoteliers’ performance has been
outstanding. It’s a recognized force today than ever
before; people know they don’t have a choice but to
do business with them if you want to grow. Brands
— like Hilton, Holiday Inns or Marriott — they have
all come to understand what AAHOA is and how important
its members are to their growth.”
According to D.J. Rama almost 90 percent of the second-generation
joins the family business after their education, and
many want to jump into big brands and upscale properties:
“They are all very aggressive, like tigers, who are
wanting to move with speed. Sometimes, it is dangerous,
because you ought to take natural steps rather than
jumping steps — and that’s the issue with second generation.
We have a big balloon, but sometimes we don’t realize
that the air can go out in the real world. But it’s
good to have that energy level.”
He believes the second generation brings in new talents,
looking at the business from different perspective,
undertaking projects they can be proud of, and not
simply projects just to get by with. They often convince
their parents to pursue bigger brand names to attract
more customers and are well educated on how to put
the project together.
“The other thing the second generation brings to the
table is marketing skills. You can build a hotel but
if you don’t have the skills to market the hotel,
then you’ve basically failed,” Rama says. “So they
bring the skills they have learnt from this society
on how to market a product. I feel the education environment
probably must have helped tremendously, which it did
for me.”
The JHM Group, like other bigger companies, also depends
on outside professionals, rather than just the family,
as it expanded. As Rama points out, You need more
professionalism, more talent, which will take you
to the next level. It’s people who take you to different
levels. Outside talent can keep the company growing.”
Another second generationer playing an active role
in the hospitality industry is Naresh Patel. He is
a self-confessed “motel kid” who grew up monitoring
the front desk or vacuuming the occasional motel room.
His parents first came to California in the 1970s
from India via England and leased their first hotel
in Los Angeles.
R.C. Patel.
When Nash, the youngest of six children, was only
9, his father died. The family relocated to Florida
and operated a small 14-unit motel in Pensacola, with
everyone pitching in. He recalls: “We used to do our
chores before we left for school. I would check out
the rooms to make sure the air-conditioning was turned
off and after school; we’d do our fair share of watching
the front desk. On weekends we’d do a little bit of
housekeeping as well.”
Gradually, as the children grew up and went to college.
They got more involved in the business and developed
their first new construction in 1990 and from there
they moved on to buying, selling and developing hotels.
Today Nash Patel and his older brother Jay are partners
in Amerifirst Network, Inc., a Built-to-Suite Development
Company, which specializes in the development of hotels,
motels and convenient stores, quick serve restaurants,
office buildings and strip centers. Nash is Senior
Vice President of Lodging Hospitality Systems, Inc.,
and a company franchising the Asbury Suites &
Inns.
Nash, who is secretary of AAHOA, and his brother Jay
have been actively involved with the organization.
Jay, who was one of the youngest board members, has
researched the issue of franchising and authored a
book titled Franchising: is it Fair? He says, “I’ve
been an advocate of trying to change the way we do
business in franchising.”
Diplomate’s AmeriSuites.
He points out that franchise agreements are always
so one-sided — franchise companies want agreements
their way — and if something goes wrong, the franchisee
could end up losing his life savings. In his book
he outlines how one could get franchises to negotiate
fairly with you and the book was adopted by AAHOA
and given to all its members. He assited the AAHOA
in developing its 12 principles that franchise companies
should adopt to make the transactions more equitable.
He says, “Because of AAHOA’s ability to push, today
I believe about 70 percent of franchisers have adopted
the AAHOA 12 points. Everybody in the industry agreed
that our points were not anything that was in favor
of franchisees, but just reflected fairness in business.”
Jay Patel also emphasizes the expertise of the second
generation of hoteliers in technology: “They do a
lot of e-commerce, they handle the hotels via the
Internet as far as reservation goes. From what it
was in the past — the hoteliers did not know the technology
— but now there’s a lot of technology involved, and
that’s just the way the industry is going.”
Second generation hoteliers are the ones who are knowledgeable
of the financing aspect as well, so they are the ones
out there hustling mezzanine and other creative financing
solutions. Explains Jay Patel: “That was not there
for the first generation of moteliers, because there
was no education provided to them on how they can
obtain financing. They were fortunate to find the
properties through owner financing and some used to
lease hotels, because it was hard to get financing.”
Another noteworthy trend in the industry is the active
involvement of women. Earlier whole families were
involved in the upkeep and running but now young women
are approaching it in a more professional way, pursuing
degrees in college to equip themselves to join the
industry. Priti Patel, who graduated from the University
of Tennessee with a degree in business and property
management, returned to the family business to develop
a new Country Inn & Suites in Kennesaw, Ga.
While her husband Sudhir is a project coordinator
for Delta Technology, Priti has embraced the business
she grew up in. She recalls, “My mom and dad had an
independent hotel and we lived on property. So we
did everything; operations is what I did my whole
life. If a maid didn’t show up, you lent a hand. I
wouldn’t be the one sitting in the corner, crying.”
Operations mean everything from accounting to sales
to front desk to housekeeping, and Priti Patel has
done it all. She has seen the properties themselves
change from 18, 20, 30 rooms to an average of 50 or
60. JHM Hotels.
She says, “I feel the second generation just is more
professional and they take care of business outside
of family. We separate it a little more than are parents
did. That’s the way I view it. We have a tendency
to keep employees and business really separate from
home. We’ve all moved up from independent mom and
pop franchises and are now moving more into the Hiltons
and Marriotts now.”
Patel has seen the participation of women increase
over the years in the management of hotels as well
as in AAHOA. She recalls, “When I first started in
1997, I was one of two women who got elected to the
board, along with 30 men.” Since the participation
of women was very low at conventions, AAHOA decided
to have a women’s conference to get them involved
and over 500 women attended that first leadership
conference Surekha Patel, who was AAHOA’s
chair for the Women Hoteliers Committee in 2000 and
2001, continued the task by introducing new programs
and events. Surekha, along with her husband Chandrakant,
is a founding director of the State Bank of Texas,
which has $150 million in assets and has four branches.
9/11 has impacted the hotel industry. Fear of terrorism,
security concerns, a ravaged economy and the prospects
of an impending war have taken their toll. Says Mike
Amin, “It is very difficult out there. It’s in a holding
pattern right now. There are very few new developments.
Right now with travel, tourism, corporate spending,
tech business, everything being on the downward trend,
I think most of our members are basically holding
on and trying to cut costs, and effectively manage
those properties as best as they can. People are rethinking
their investment strategy.”
Nash Patel.
Indeed, D.J. Rama points out: “The people you depend
on who travel the roads every day are the people who
are sitting there watching events unfold on TV and
wondering ‘Should we be out there spending the extra
hundred dollars that we have for this weekend?’ So
the situation .has indirectly affected 99 percent
of the hotel owners and they will have to find ways
to weather the storm.”
Priti Patel says a lot of properties in Atlanta are
hurting with occupancy rates down significantly. She
says, “I was just telling a friend that in the ‘80s
when business was slow, I was so young I didn’t really
know. Our parents lived through it. Now it’s our turn
to live through situations like this.”
She says they’ve had to become more hands-on and cut
back on staffing.
Across the hotel industry there is considerable belt-tightening
and new projects have been put on hold. The more upscale
properties have been harder hit than the limited service
segment, where costs can be cut faster.
According to Pricewaterhouse Coopers, profits in the
hotel industry declined by 27.4 percent from $23 billion
in 2000 to $16.7 billion in 2001. Profits grew nominally
to $17.2 billion in 2002, as a result of cost reductions.
Although the economy remains troubled, 2003 profits
are forecast to rise to $19.8 billion.
“Had the industry not responded quickly, profits would
have decreased by 7.8 percent to $15.4 billion this
year,” says Bjorn Hanson, PricewaterhouseCoopers Hospitality
& Leisure Practice. “Some of these cost reductions
seem to be institutionalized, and some can only continue
for a limited time or they will affect the quality
of facilities and guest service.”
D.J. Rama says these are one of the worst times hoteliers
have seen, with the lowest occupancy rates in 31 years:
“The industry will rebound, but it will rebound with
discipline. The corporate people who used to come
to us are more disciplined about spending their money
or making visits to corporate offices. They may make
five phone calls rather than a visit. It’s not going
to be the way it used to be. So what we are doing
in our company is making sure that our discipline
is in place for taking any level of business and making
sure we are successful at it.”
Some hoteliers are also realizing that all the eggs
shouldn’t be put in one basket, and are diversifying
into different fields.
Almost 40 percent
of Cendant Corporation’s properties are Asian
R.C.Patel and his brother Mike head the Diplomat Group
of Companies and are prominent in the lodging industry.
They came to Alabama. in 1980, from England, via East
Africa. In London, they ran corner shops and operated
a small bed and breakfast establishment. They purchased
their first Holiday Inn, becoming the first Indians
to own a franchise hotel in Alabama. Over the next
20 years they bought and sold 45 hotels. Today the
Diplomat Group currently own 17 hotels with 3,000
rooms in the Southeast, including Red Roof, Hampton
and Best Western brands.
Three years ago they founded the Horizon Bank in Atlanta
and they also offer SBA financing, which is crucial
for financing for property purchase. Observes R.J.
Patel, “The way the landscape of America is changing,
we felt there was a need for a community owned Indian
bank.”
They pulled friends together and after 18 months managed
to get a charter from the banking commission. Today
the bank has $90 million in assets and its clients
include the hotel community, convenience store owners
and physicians looking to buy medical practice buildings.
“The future of the hotel industry is not too good.
There’s no money to be made in operations, because
people are using the Internet boom to shop rates,
and the rates are coming down,” says R.C. Patel. “The
occupancy is still around, but the rates are not there.”
He points out that eight years ago, after the last
recession, people still made money but this time around
it is much harder. New developments across the country
have halved, with just 80,000 new rooms being built
from a high of 160,000 hotels.
With an eye on the ledger, the Diplomat Group has
diversified into development and construction and
has been selected by Six Continents to develop its
new prototype of Holiday Inn. The brothers have also
started an insurance company and R.C. Patel’s sons,
who are studying investment banking and risk management,
will join them in the diverse family business.
As the hospitality industry reinvents itself to reflect
the changing environment, the family closeness and
affinity for this business will ensure that Indians
continue to play a leading role. D.J. Rama who grew
up in motels and hotels now is father to a toddler.
Does he see him joining the family business?
“He’s only four years old, so it’s hard to predict!”
he laughs. “But I’d love for him to join and take
the business to the next level. It’s like we are building
sandcastles near the ocean — our fathers built one
— and we’re always afraid that while we are sleeping
at night, it might get washed away. “As a child I
was always brought up to believe that you have to
protect your father’s sweat equity, the hard work
that he and his brothers did. I hope my son also comes
in and makes sure that the sandcastle is protected
from the ocean and never gets washed away.”